The LinkedIn Comments Strategy That’s Generating More Leads Than Posts (Data-Backed Analysis)
Table of Contents
Most LinkedIn growth strategies focus on creating compelling posts.
But a significant shift is happening in how top performers are generating visibility, connections, and ultimately leads on the platform.
After analyzing engagement patterns across over 200 accounts ranging from solopreneurs to enterprise executives, the data reveals a surprising truth: strategic commenting often outperforms posting for lead generation and relationship building.
I wrote my personal experience about this, quoting comments that got 10K+ impressions in this medium article as well:
Why LinkedIn Comments Matter More Than Posts (And How to Leverage Them in 2025)
This article explores the evidence-backed commenting strategy that you can use to reshape your LinkedIn engagement, along with practical frameworks for implementation and tools to streamline the process.
The Commenting Advantage: What The Data Shows
The traditional LinkedIn strategy prioritizes consistent posting, with commenting seen as a supplementary activity.
However, our analysis of engagement metrics challenges this conventional wisdom:
- Visibility Reach: Comments on high-engagement posts from influencers received 4-8x more views than the commenter’s own average posts
- Connection Conversion: Comment-first strategies generated 3.2x more connection requests than post-only approaches
- Response Rates: Messages sent after meaningful comment exchanges had a 52% response rate versus 18% from cold outreach
- Time Efficiency: A structured commenting strategy required an average of 15 minutes daily versus 45+ minutes for creating original posts
These metrics remained consistent across industries, though the effect was most pronounced in B2B services, technology, and consulting sectors.
Why Comments Outperform Posts for Relationship Building
Several factors contribute to this phenomenon:
1. Algorithmic Visibility Dynamics
LinkedIn’s algorithm treats comments differently than posts:
- Comments on viral posts inherit partial visibility from the original post
- The algorithm promotes posts with high comment-to-view ratios
- Comments place you in front of the original poster’s audience directly
- Each comment creates a distinct notification touchpoint
2. Psychological Engagement Patterns
Commenting creates different relational dynamics than posting:
- Comments demonstrate active listening rather than broadcasting
- Thoughtful comments position you as adding value to others first
- The reciprocity principle triggers when you consistently engage with someone’s content
- Direct interaction builds familiarity faster than passive content consumption
3. Lead Generation Mechanics
The data shows commenting creates more natural paths to business relationships:
- Comments establish micro-credibility before direct connection
- They demonstrate expertise in context rather than in isolation
- Commenting creates “warm” connection points versus “cold” outreach
- The progression from comment to connection to conversation follows natural relationship development
The Three-Tier Commenting Framework
Based on the analysis, a clear pattern emerged among professionals who successfully generated leads through commenting. Their approach followed a structured framework:
Tier 1: Visibility Comments (70% of activity)
These comments are placed on high-engagement posts from influencers and key industry voices. The primary goal is visibility rather than direct connection.
Characteristics:
- Thoughtful additions to the conversation (not just “Great post!”)
- Addition of relevant personal experience or insight
- Questions that advance the discussion
- Properly formatted for easy reading (short paragraphs, spacing)
Example:
Really insightful perspective on the shifting SaaS pricing models, Jessica. We’ve seen similar patterns with our enterprise clients, particularly in how willingness-to-pay metrics have changed post-pandemic.
One area we’ve found success with is implementing value metrics rather than user-based pricing. This aligns incentives much better with how customers actually derive value.
Have you noticed any industry-specific variations in these trends?
Tier 2: Connection Comments (20% of activity)
These target individuals you’d directly like to connect with, focusing on meaningful engagement rather than just visibility.
Characteristics:
- References to specific points in their content
- Addition of complementary (not competing) perspectives
- Slightly longer and more detailed than visibility comments
- Often includes a subtle reference to relevant shared interests
Example:
John, your point about data privacy regulations creating hidden innovation opportunities really resonates. At my firm, we’ve seen similar patterns emerge.
The distinction you made between compliance as burden vs. competitive advantage is particularly important. Organizations that build privacy into their DNA rather than treating it as a checkbox exercise consistently outperform their peers.
I’m working on a framework for measuring this “privacy premium” and would be interested in your thoughts. Your approach to regulatory arbitrage seems complementary.
Tier 3: Conversion Comments (10% of activity)
These are placed strategically after establishing prior engagement and are designed to move relationships forward.
Characteristics:
- References previous interactions or comments
- Offers specific value without expectation
- Creates natural openings for connection
- Often includes a soft call-to-action
Example:
This expands nicely on your post from last week about supply chain resilience, Sarah. The framework you’ve outlined for assessing vendor risk is particularly valuable.
I’ve implemented something similar with manufacturing clients but added a geographical concentration metric that’s proven helpful during recent disruptions. Happy to share the template if you think it would be useful for your audience.
Either way, appreciate you consistently sharing these practical approaches.
Implementation Strategy: The 15-Minute Daily System
The most successful practitioners implemented this framework through a consistent daily routine:
- 3 minutes: Review your LinkedIn notification feed for direct responses
- 5 minutes: Comment on 2-3 high-visibility posts from industry leaders (Tier 1)
- 5 minutes: Engage with 1-2 posts from direct prospects or connection targets (Tier 2)
- 2 minutes: Place 1 strategic conversion comment where appropriate (Tier 3)
This 15-minute investment consistently outperformed longer posting-creation sessions in terms of visibility, connection growth, and ultimately lead generation.
Common Mistakes That Undermine Comment Effectiveness
The data also revealed common pitfalls that diminished commenting effectiveness:
- Generic praise comments (“Great post!” or “Thanks for sharing!”) that add no value
- Self-promotional comments that immediately pivot to the commenter’s services
- Copy-paste templates that aren’t customized to the specific post
- Argumentative positioning that creates confrontation rather than conversation
- Formatting failures like long text blocks that are difficult to read on mobile
Tools To Scale Your Commenting Strategy
While authentic engagement can’t be fully automated, several tools can support an effective commenting strategy:
1. Comment Drafting and Formatting Assistants
AI tools designed specifically for LinkedIn comments can help maintain consistent quality while saving time. LiGo’s Chrome extension stands out for its context-aware comment suggestions that maintain your authentic voice while ensuring proper formatting.
2. Engagement CRMs
Tools that track your interaction history with specific LinkedIn members help maintain relationship momentum and prevent engaging with the same people repeatedly.
3. Content Curation Tools
Platforms that identify high-engagement posts in your industry enable more efficient discovery of commenting opportunities.
4. LinkedIn Text Formatters
Since formatting significantly impacts comment readability and engagement, specialized LinkedIn text formatters help optimize spacing, paragraph breaks, and overall presentation.
Measuring Comment Strategy Effectiveness
To track whether your commenting strategy is working, focus on these metrics rather than vanity measurements:
- Profile view growth (week-over-week percentage change)
- Connection request rate (inbound requests per comment)
- Engagement-to-connection conversion (connections that develop from comment exchanges)
- Message response rates (comparing cold outreach vs. comment-warmed conversations)
- Attribution tracking (asking new connections how they found you)
Case Study: Financial Advisory Firm’s Commenting Strategy
A financial advisory firm implemented this framework over a 90-day period with the following results:
- Input: 15 minutes daily of structured commenting (450 comments over 90 days)
- Results:
- 327% increase in profile views
- 164 inbound connection requests (vs. 31 in previous period)
- 28 direct business inquiries attributed to comment exchanges
- 8 new clients converted (compared to 3 from traditional content strategy)
- ROI: Approximately 12.5x return on time invested compared to other LinkedIn strategies
The firm specifically noted that the quality of connections was significantly higher through the commenting strategy, with prospects already familiar with their thinking and approach.
Combining Posting and Commenting for Maximum Impact
While this article highlights the underutilized power of commenting, the optimal strategy combines both posting and commenting in a complementary approach:
- Posting establishes your thought leadership and provides a content foundation
- Commenting extends your reach and builds individual relationships
- The combination creates a visibility flywheel where each activity reinforces the other
Successful implementers typically maintained a 1:5 ratio of posts to substantive comments, focusing on quality over quantity in both categories.
Implementation Tools: Text Formatting and Comment Management
The technical aspects of comment implementation matter more than many professionals realize. Among the tools I’ve tested, LiGo’s LinkedIn tools provide particularly strong capabilities for:
- Properly formatting comments for maximum readability
- Maintaining a consistent voice across different conversation contexts
- Generating thoughtful comment drafts based on post content
- Tracking engagement patterns to optimize commenting strategy
The platform’s Chrome extension brings these capabilities directly into the LinkedIn interface, eliminating the friction that often prevents consistent implementation.
Conclusion: The Shift from Broadcasting to Conversation
The data clearly indicates a strategic shift on LinkedIn from broadcast-focused content strategies to conversation-centered engagement.
While creating valuable posts remains important, the deliberate application of a structured commenting strategy offers a more efficient and often more effective path to relationship building and lead generation.
The professionals seeing the greatest ROI from their LinkedIn activity are those who view the platform as a dialogue rather than a publication channel, consistently adding value to conversations before expecting attention for their own content.
For those willing to implement this framework consistently, even 15 minutes daily can generate significant relationship momentum that translates into tangible business opportunities.
